Mike Lipper’s Monday Morning Musings
Selling:
Art & Risks, Current & Later
Editors: Frank
Harrison 1997-2018, Hylton Phillips-Page 2018
Most Difficult Decision
After a decision is made to
purchase one or more securities the level of complexity escalates through one
or more holding periods. The act of selling has immediate performance
implications, but also has implications for the rest of the lives of the
investor, their inheritors, and various governments. Because of these
implications, the decision process should consider factors wider than the simple
decision to purchase.
Decision Making
Individual investors
often start their investment process by thinking about “their” money and its
personal use. Over time their thinking may broaden to include their responsibilities,
leading them to start thinking of themselves more as fiduciaries. Most
investment money, including that in various institutions, is managed with
fiduciary principles in mind.
However, when we bring a
professional fiduciary into the picture, the decision dynamics evolve. The
fiduciary unsurprisingly wants to be compensated. More importantly, in our
litigious society fiduciaries want to avoid being sued. Most suits are decided
on the basis of the 1830 Putnam vs Harvard (Prudent Person) case, which holds
the fiduciary performance standard to what other prudent people would do with their
money. This is a backward-looking judicial view. (This approach created the
performance measurement business, which benefited the author and my various
associates.)
While this approach is addressed
by the so-called “Prudent Person” decision process, it doesn’t make a lot of
sense for a forward-looking investor. For example, if a manager stays fully
invested in a speculative securities market decline and vastly underperforms a
more diversified portfolio, he would be judged imprudent for the declining investment
period. However, if the measurement period included the recovery and a subsequent
growth period, the entire period might be much longer than desired for a more
conservatively managed account.
Where Are We Today?
Since we look at investing through short to long-term periods, the following views express an opinion, not a prediction as to three stimuli.
- Investors are fleeing China, driving many prices down. If you are a trading investor who values short-term performance, it might make sense to reduce exposure. However, there are two reasons that suggest the opposite.
1. Betting
against volume normally works better than the opposite.
2. Without
the growth of Chinese exports, world growth will be constrained.
- The three major US stock market indices had a dull to sloppy week. The S&P 500, representing the bulk of investor’s capital, fell slightly through a technical barrier. While not a prediction, it could suggest the calendar year might finish with small gains for the year. If that turns out to be true it would confirm we are in a period of stagflation similar to FDR’s depression and a model for Joe Biden.
- All three dominant political leaders: Biden, Trump, and Xi, were/are concerned with the need to create employment opportunities for younger voters and spenders. History shows others using effective ways to accomplish this goal.
- In ancient Rome, legionnaires were awarded captured farmland to provide food for Roman staff. It also served to cultivate political capital. The building of the viaducts was also needed to bring food to Rome.
- President Eisenhower pushed a national highway system, which improved interstate commerce and employed private workers. Ike had the benefit of several knowledgeable brothers, which were Presidents at local banks and Universities.
- Xi has possibly built the biggest and fastest railroad system in the world. US rail and airport infrastructure is way below many third world countries.
Now it is Your Turn
The ultimate value of
these blogs is to raise discussion of these controversial views. Let’s hear from
you.
Did you miss my blog last week? Click here to read.
Mike
Lipper's Blog: Investment Thinking During a Lull - Weekly Blog # 802
Mike Lipper's Blog: Need For a Correction
Decline - Weekly Blog # 801
Mike Lipper's Blog: Not Yet! - Weekly
blog # 800
Did someone forward you this blog?
To receive Mike Lipper’s Blog each Monday morning,
please subscribe by emailing me directly at AML@Lipperadvising.com
Copyright © 2008 – 2023
Michael Lipper, CFA
All rights reserved.
Contact author for limited redistribution permission.