The Biggest Risk We All Face - Weekly Blog # 674

 

Mike Lipper’s Monday Morning Musings

The Biggest Risk We All Face

Editors: Frank Harrison 1997-2018, Hylton Phillips-Page 2018 –

Self- Inflicted Risk

While many try, nobody commands how we make decisions. That is why each of us are ingenious in building our own strict prisons. Our jailers are what we choose to believe or not believe. It is that process which leads to our single biggest investment risk: Conformation Bias. While we are very conscious of the endless sources of facts and opinions in this modern era, the way we deal with too much information is to ignore much and accept some of the inputs. 

I cannot improve on your own selection process but will attempt to aid you in assessing the strength of your convictions. In this way I hope to improve the consequences of deeply held beliefs. For centuries, most people held firm to the belief that we lived on a flat earth. The consequence of that firm belief led to the economic disadvantage of not finding other parts of the world and not understanding weather patterns.

With apologies to subscribers for another example of learning from my most important educational source, the racetrack. The ranking of other bettors’ beliefs before each race are the winning odds on each participant, measured by the number of bettors favoring a particular horse multiplied by the amount of money bet. The generally known percentage history of the most favored horses winning is way below half and closer to one-third. Few pay attention to the percent return on each successful horse, which tends to be much bigger. For example, in a race where the most favored horse pays off at even money, a bettor would cash a winning $2.00 ticket for $4.00. If a 10 to 1 shot is the winner, the winning $2 ticket receives $22, or 5.5 times the cash payoff of the even money winner. (The payoffs are after track fees and local taxes.) The job of a good portfolio manager, using this example, is to pick at least one of three races vs. the even money bettor.

In the long run it is more profitable to somewhat invest in greatly unpopular securities and funds rather than those that are popular, which is why understanding Confirmation Bias is so important.

A Self-Administered Test of Your Confirmation Bias

The following is a list of controversial statements, not necessarily my beliefs. There are six alternative buckets for your beliefs: Believe (80%-100%/40%-60%/10%-20%) and Disbelieve (80%-100%/40%-60%/10%-20%). Where appropriate, place the strength of your belief or disbelief in each of the columns, as shown in the italicized example below:

                                                                                                

                                                                                                                  10%-20%/40%-60%/80%-100%

Statement                                   Beliefs       Disbeliefs 

“Money is the Mothers’ Milk Of Politics (1) 80%-100%        10%-20%                                           

1. “Money is the Mothers’ Milk Of Politics   

2. Redistribute Capital to Redistribute Votes 

3. Need More Union Dues Contributions

4. Higher Taxes, Lower Growth

5. “Value” Better than “Growth” for 10 Years

6. Drawdowns 34%-49% (2)

Complete the table below by placing a check under one of the belief columns and one of the disbelief columns, answering for each of these six questions above. 

               Beliefs                        Disbeliefs 

      80%-100%  40%-60%  10%-20%      80%-100%  40%-60%  10%-20%

1.

2. 

3.

4.

5.

6.

1. A statement by Jesse Unruh, speaker of the California House and supporter of each of the three Kennedy Brothers.
2. In the last 23 years, the annual decline of the S&P 500 was -49% in 2008 and -34% in 1987, 2002 and 2020. 

If your beliefs or disbeliefs are dominant in either column, you are at risk of Conformity Bias and should examine the opposite point of view. This will enable you to set up an early warning signaling the pendulum is swinging in the opposite direction to your basic beliefs.

What to Do?

The most difficult job of a good portfolio manager is to periodically balance different points of view and quickly recognize early warning signs of a change. (At the track, a sudden shift in odds indicates new money has a different view, which should be re-examined to see if it contains new information which merits a change of opinion.) 

It is rare for our fiduciary portfolios to not have elements of growth and value. This is particularly true when the portfolio is broken down into sub-portfolios based on different payment and volatility needs. Currently, another major focus is domestic versus international, with China being under a controlled slowing and the US possibly being under a dangerous induced expansion.

Brief Updates 

Each of the following could be developed into its own blog, but I will spare you, although I’m happy to discuss these items with subscribers offline.

1. There are rumors of the administration thinking about instituting a tax on miles driven. Also, there is talk of an excess profits tax on those individuals and companies that appeared to have made money due to the pandemic and lockdowns.
2. Union membership has been cut in half since 1975, when it was 20% of the workforce, but it has risen a bit very recently.
3. The NASDAQ vs NYSE, which is the leader? In terms of year over year volume, NYSE -34.69% vs NASDAQ +30.50%. New lows in terms of the percentage of issues traded, NYSE 7.6% vs NASDAQ 11.9%. The relative absence of passive investors in the NASDAQ may be causing the difference.
4. The JOC-ECRI Industrial Price Index year over year is +83.7%. (Closer to home, Ruth mentioned that not only are food prices going up at the supermarket, but also paper products. It would be reasonable to assume packaging costs are increasing too. Paper, and energy for trucks, are part of the JOC index.)
5. The AAII bullish/bearish reading is 50.9%/20.6%
6. The largest free cash flow sector is Financials.
7. Large commodity speculators are increasing their short positions over their growing long positions in copper, crude oil, gold, live cattle, silver, T Bonds, wheat, and the Yen.
8. Small-Cap Value mutual funds are the leading diversified mutual fund peer group +20.46%. Mutual Funds should be important to other investors as 47.4% of US households own mutual funds.
9. James Mackintosh mentioned in the WSJ that the three stages of debt expansion are: speed, stimulus, and inflation, as evolved by Hyman Minsky.
10. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) believes it would be too difficult to cut the existing budget to cover all the new administration’s planned expenditures.

Special Announcement to my fellow Analysts

Over the weekend the New York Times (NYT) published an article on the death of Bernadette Bartels Murphy. She was a former President of the New York Society of Security Analysts, as was I. Bernadette re-popularized chart reading and helped put the Market Technicians on their feet. When I talk with portfolio managers who have survived the cyclicality of the marketplace, they rarely couch their thinking about market analysis, as many benefitted from her efforts. We and the market have lost a major contributor to our progress.

 

PS

Early Asian trades are reacting to rumors of substantial forced margin account liquidations, probably from hedge funds. This could be a problem for the US Monday morning.

Did you miss my blog last week? Click here to read.

https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2021/03/2-presidential-lessons-to-be.html

https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2021/03/mike-lippers-monday-morning-musings.html

https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2021/03/next-race-winner-weekly-blog-671.html

Did someone forward you this blog? 

To receive Mike Lipper’s Blog each Monday morning, please subscribe by emailing me directly at AML@Lipperadvising.com

Copyright © 2008 - 2020

A. Michael Lipper, CFA

All rights reserved.

Contact author for limited redistribution permission.