Mike Lipper’s Monday Morning Musings
Successful Investing Expects the Unexpected
And The Berkshire Hathaway Solution
Editors: Frank Harrison 1997-2018, Hylton Phillips-Page 2018 –
This was the week that demonstrated that successful investing is an artform, not a science. Most professional investors entered the week secure in their certified knowledge of investment accounting and regulations. These are essential, but insufficient to avoid losses and capture gains from unexpected changes. An understanding of history, particularly military history, is a very useful tool. Additionally, an understanding of the behavior of beneficiaries of large wealth is also helpful in managing both personal and other accounts.
In the US Marine Corps, whenever possible, each major amphibious landing conducts dress rehearsals. Hitler did even more, he tested his air force and underground “fifth column” tactics and equipment in the Spanish Civil War, which prepared his forces for their “blitzkrieg” attack on the Western front. I find it interesting to compare the personalities of Hitler and Putin. Both increasingly became more isolated from their associates, leading to personalized decision making rather than a more controlled group analysis. The picture that was released showing a meeting with Macron and others at a very elongated table is a sign of his isolation. His mental condition led to the false historical positions in Putin’s speech that started his troops moving.
The history of US retreats from Vietnam, the Middle East, and Afghanistan, encouraged his view. The view that US and Western European countries would not quickly and strenuously defend against his restoration of the old Soviet borders. None of these analyses are taught in CFA classes or law schools. Thus, the investment community was largely unprepared for the critical change to the real environment we faced this weekend.
My fellow analysts, in response to the needs of their marketeers, have become scribes of reported results and near-term rumors, where predictions are largely extrapolations of present trends. Rarely are there any predictions of trend reversals, nor the identification of new competitors. Most importantly, they rarely focus on the attitudinal changes of beneficiaries of critical assets.
Probable Changes Coming to Berkshire Hathaway
I have been taken to task concerning my expressed view that after the “saintly investment lives of Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, and many of their 80 or so operating officers are over, there will likely be a move to breakup Berkshire. Analysts are thus violating one of the tenants of sound advice, which is to predict outcomes, whether favorable or not.
Berkshire is one of the largest holdings in our family accounts and it has produced very gratifying results for many years. Nevertheless, I perceive a dramatic change in the shareholder population on the horizon. I am extremely grateful that the present management has run the company for the beneficiaries of the present shareholders, rather than generating assets for their own consumption, unlike most public companies.
I suspect that those readers of this blog that have experienced asset transfers between generations and have noted a largely consistent pattern, beneficiaries failing to retain the older generations’ investment advisors and/or investment philosophies. After years of waiting to make their own decisions with “their” money, the first thing they do is sell out of their inheritance. They might be a bit slower if they realized there would be a materially higher valuation placed of their inheritance.
Messrs. Buffett and Munger have built a portfolio of assets with different risks and rewards based on the type of economy. I firmly believe numerous operational and investment assets could be sold to higher bidders, increasing leverage and assuming more risk. Charlie Munger has said that not every asset they own is likely to be worth their carrying value at a particular time. To the extent that individual assets are hedges against other assets, a one-time complete breakup of the company would destroy the hedging value laboriously built into the portfolio. (I am comfortable with this portfolio approach. As an investor in mutual funds, I judge their value based on their overall performance patterns over time. By definition, funds never do as well as their best position or as badly as their worst.)
In the future, I expect a significant portion of Berkshire stock to shift to new owners. Many of the new owners would likely support an attempt to convert their wonderful inheritance into a bigger pile, showing their departed grantors that the new owners are brighter than those that gifted the money. I DO NOT SUPPORT A BREAKUP STRATEGY, but that will not preclude it from happening.
There is an intermediate strategy which could be a better approach. In the past, Berkshire has not been copied by other companies in the past in advised other investors on how they do things. In terms of of operations and investment and how they manage a holding company to generate free cash flow and tax assets. I am hopeful the same kind of ingenuity that produced the $147 billion “float” can be applied to the company. This might create a holding company like Allegheny Corp, in which I own a few shares. Allegheny owns both minority, majority and 100% ownership in a number very diversified companies, with a goal of building book value. Whether we like it or not, youth will control Berkshire at some point, and we need to recognize it.
Weekly View
While it is possible there will soon be an end to hostilities, I don’t expect we will see a strengthened position of the Western allies, both in terms of Russia and China. We need to be prepared for problems arising out our past weaknesses.
Did you miss my blog last week? Click here to read.
https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2022/02/we-are-progressing-weekly-blog-721.html
https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2022/02/building-long-term-investment.html
https://mikelipper.blogspot.com/2022/02/changing-focus-in-changing-world-weekly.html
Did someone forward you this blog?
To receive Mike Lipper’s Blog each Monday morning, please subscribe by emailing me directly at AML@Lipperadvising.com
Copyright © 2008 - 2020
A. Michael Lipper, CFA
All rights reserved.
Contact author for limited redistribution permission.
Posts
